Caimito house first listed at $6 million sells for $3.65 million
A house at 2003 Calle José Fidalgo Díaz in Urbanización La Cumbre, Caimito, San Juan, sold for $3,650,000, according to property records analysed by RED Atlas. The sale deed (deed 10) was recorded on May 30, 2026, together with a $2,920,000 mortgage from FirstBank Puerto Rico, 80% of the price, and the cancellation of an earlier $1,500,000 mortgage on the property. The buyer and the seller are private parties.
Priced down from $6 million
Listing sites had offered the house at $6,000,000 in 2024, at $5,500,000 by December 2024 and at $4,600,000 from August 2025, before marking it sold at $3,650,000 in the autumn of 2025. The listings describe seven bedrooms and five bathrooms in about 993 m2 (10,686 sq ft) of interior space, which puts the deed price at about $3,676 per m2, or about $342 per sq ft.
The registry had recorded a declaration of completed construction on the property in June 2025, valued at $3,000,000, so the house is a recent build. The lot's last recorded sale before that was in December 1998, for $350,000.
The property
The lot covers 3,430 m2 in the property records, is zoned R-1 and is classed as urban land in the Puerto Rico Land Use Plan.
Sales in Caimito and San Juan
In the 12 months from November 2024 to October 2025, the Caimito neighbourhood recorded 253 sale deeds at a median price of $225,000, against 291 deeds at a median of $220,000 in the 12 months before. The whole municipality of San Juan recorded 5,306 sale deeds at a median of $160,000 in the later year, against 5,736 at $145,000 the year before. Sellers listing residential property in San Juan asked a median $357,228 in October 2026.